Written by

Amy Kirk - Associate & Chartered Legal Executive

A Patient Claim Line Case Study

A 60-year-old man has been left with a severe testes injury following a routine surgery, of which he was not forewarned of the risks.


The Incident


The gentleman, who prefers not to be named, visited United Lincolnshire Hospital for a recurrent inguinal hernia repair. He was not warned of the risks associated with this type of surgery, and therefore informed consent to carry out the procedure was not granted.


The Case


Our client was represented by Chartered Legal Executive, Amy Kirk.


The case was settled at a round table meeting (RTM) whereby the defendant argued that even if the claimant was warned about the risk, he would have continued with the surgery. Regardless, Amy argued that our client was not given the opportunity to provide informed consent, as he was not warned of the risks prior to agreeing with the surgery.


The Aftermath


Following the surgery, our client was left with severe injuries which he was unable to prepare for. The full list of injuries are as follows:


• Ischemic orchitis – R testicular atrophy
• Swelling and discomfort (constant dull ache)
• Urinary urgency
• Emotional distress and anxiety


The Outcome


The case was settled at £9,250 in our client’s favour.


Amy explains:


“Consent cases are inherently difficult, and it is of upmost importance to take detailed instructions from your client in order to argue their case for them. This case also highlights the benefits of RTMs.”



Amy Kirk is a Chartered Legal Executive / FCILEx at Patient Claim Line

Medical negligence can occur during any time of your surgery, including the pre-operative stage. If you have experienced any surgical medical negligence similar to the case above then please visit our Negligent surgery claims page to find out more information and to see if you could make a claim today.

Concerned about your medical treatment?

Contact us today!

"*" indicates required fields